Blog #2 Western Thoughts and Turner

To begin, I’ve started my research into my idea for my final project regarding the roles law enforcement and vigilantism played in the West, and like most looks into Western law enforcement and justice, my first stopping point has been the Gunfight at/near/a block from the O.K. Corral. What I always felt to be a rather simple story of officers versus outlaws has quickly spiraled into a complicated weave of family, grudges, town politics, the Civil War, cattlemen vs. ranchers, and much, much more. I really should not have been surprised, considering the most scholarly look into the gunfight I had prior to starting this class was an “edu-tainment” television show. ‘History Actually Much More Complicated Than Hollywood Portrays’ probably won’t lead the New York Times any time soon.

That fictional headline does, however, lead rather well into our author this week: Frederick Jackson Turner, one of the major perpetrators of the West as myth. Turner’s West is one where men were Men, patriotically setting out to conquer both Wilderness and Wild Man in the name of Civilization, Progress, and America. Of course, this West is devoid of women, minorities, and the countless individual motivations we read about last week, and that of the natives is only as Savages to be turned to Civilization. The West as envisioned by Turner, though a sappy story, seems dull and boring compared to the more complex and realistic versions seen in more modern scholarship. Perhaps the emptiness in Turner’s West was made up some by all the capital letters.

Snarky jabs aside, Turner has his own point in time, and scholarship in the almost century since Turner have ripped his idealized version of the West up one side and down the other. Turner’s West has its place in national myth, but myth does not mean history, and real life is certainly not a Hollywood movie or television show.

If it was, I’d certainly demand a much better soundtrack.

I commented on Megan’s and Beth’s blogs.

Advertisements

One thought on “Blog #2 Western Thoughts and Turner

  1. I love your idea to examine vigilantism and law enforcement for your final paper. It brought to mind Amy Louise Wood’s book Lynching and Spectacle: Witnessing Racial Violence in America, 1890-1940. Her work may fall a little outside of your specific focus, but vigilantism fascinates me. We still see it today: a Texas father made headlines a while back for attacking his child’s molester, for example. Officially, on paper, we condemn the idea of taking the law into one’s own hands. And yet, this father was held with widespread sympathy. We often portray our western heroes as delivering righteous justice when acting outside the law – I’m thinking specifically of one of my favorite mini-series, Lonesome Dove. Once Texas Rangers, Call and Gus mete out justice as they deem appropriate all the way from Texas to Montana. What a great idea to explore!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s